Acrylic vs. Glass Windows: Comparison for Underwater Glazing

Acrylic (cast PMMA) and laminated safety glass are the two transparent materials that can hold back high water pressure. Both are used for pool windows, glass pool walls, aquariums and ship windows. Below the waterline, acrylic is usually the better choice: it stays clear even when it is very thick, does not shatter, weighs less than half as much and can be made into very long or curved panels. Glass has the harder surface. This page compares both materials property by property and explains what each point means for an underwater window.

Acrylic vs. Glass Windows: Comparison for Underwater Glazing

At a Glance

The main differences between cast acrylic and laminated safety glass of the thickness needed under water. Green marks the better value, red the weaker one.

Property Cast acrylic (PMMA) Laminated safety glass
Light transmission about 92 %, above 88 % even in very thick panels about 75–85 % for thick low-iron laminates
Color colorless green tint in thick standard glass
Under overload deforms, does not shatter brittle; sheets crack, the interlayer holds the fragments
Density 1.19 g/cm³ about 2.5 g/cm³
Thermal conductivity 0.19 W/(m·K) about 0.8–1.0 W/(m·K)
Panel length up to 11 m, longer walls bonded seamlessly limited by sheet size, joints or posts
Curved panels thermoformed possible, with limits
UV radiation no yellowing with UV-stabilized cast acrylic glass unaffected, interlayer must resist UV and moisture
Surface softer; scratches can be polished out hard; scratches cannot be removed
Fire combustible non-combustible
Thermal expansion about 70 × 10⁻⁶/K about 9 × 10⁻⁶/K

Light Transmission and Clarity

Light transmission (VLT, visible light transmission) is the share of visible light that passes through a panel. Two things reduce it:

  • Reflection at the surfaces: every clear panel reflects about 4 % of the light at its front and about 4 % at its back. This is why no clear panel exceeds about 92 %, however thin and pure it is.
  • Absorption inside the material: this part grows with the thickness – and here acrylic and glass differ.

Acrylic absorbs very little visible light and has no color of its own. Clear cast acrylic lets through about 92 %; even panels many centimeters thick typically keep more than 88–90 % and still look colorless.

Glass contains iron oxide, which absorbs mainly red light. In a thin pane you hardly notice it, but in thick glass it adds up to a visible green tint – you can see it at the edge of any glass pane. Low-iron glass (extra-clear glass) reduces the tint. A single 12 mm sheet of low-iron glass lets through about 90–92 %. Glass that has to hold back water pressure, however, is laminated from several sheets with clear plastic interlayers such as SGP. A laminate of four 12 mm low-iron sheets with three interlayers lets through about 75–85 %: each additional sheet and interlayer absorbs a little more light.

For an underwater window: colors under water look natural, and the view stays clear even at the thicknesses of up to 200 mm that large windows and deep water require.

Illustration: the green tint of thick laminated float glass (left) compared with colorless acrylic (right).

Illustration: the green tint of thick laminated float glass (left) compared with colorless acrylic (right).

Breakage Behavior and Safety

Glass is brittle: it does not yield before it breaks. As soon as the stress at an edge chip, a scratch or a point load exceeds its strength, a crack runs through the sheet in an instant. Laminated safety glass is built for this case: the interlayer holds the fragments together, and the remaining sheets carry the load.

Acrylic behaves differently. It has a much higher impact strength than glass, and under overload it deforms visibly before it fails. This is why acrylic has been used for decades for the viewports of submarines and research submersibles and for the windows of semi-submarines (see Underwater Windows for Ships).

For an underwater window: the difference matters most during installation. A large panel hanging from a crane, or resting on an uneven support, is exposed to point loads that glass tolerates poorly; acrylic flexes instead. Every window is calculated for the static water pressure at its depth. Dynamic loads such as earthquakes come on top – if your structural engineer specifies seismic loads, please send them with your enquiry.

Polycarbonate is even more impact-resistant than acrylic; the two are compared on a separate page.

Impact test for an acrylic spheric window, with impact mass of 560kg. Courtesy of J.Stachiw.

Impact test for an acrylic spheric window, with impact mass of 560kg. Courtesy of J.Stachiw.

Size, Shape and Weight

Cast acrylic has a density of 1.19 g/cm³, less than half that of glass (about 2.5 g/cm³). A panel of the same size and thickness weighs less than half as much, which makes transport, lifting and installation easier. Because acrylic is less stiff than glass, a panel for the same water pressure is usually thicker than a glass laminate, so the weight advantage of a finished window is smaller than the densities suggest.

Acrylic panels can be made in sizes and shapes that glass reaches only with difficulty:

  • Length: a single acrylic panel can be up to 11 m long. Longer walls are made by butt-bonding several panels into one continuous wall, or with posts between the panels (see Pool with Glass Wall).
  • Corners: two panels can be bonded into a glass corner without a frame post. The corners are bonded and then annealed in our factory.
  • Curves: acrylic can be thermoformed into curved panels.

Glass panels are limited by the size of the glass sheets and of the laminating equipment; longer glass walls need joints or posts.

Installation of a Hydrosight Control Window for a Glacier Water Tank in Iceland.

Installation of a Hydrosight Control Window for a Glacier Water Tank in Iceland.

Thermal Insulation and Condensation

Acrylic conducts heat four to five times less than glass:

Material Thermal conductivity
Air 0.03 W/(m·K)
Acrylic 0.19 W/(m·K)
Water 0.6 W/(m·K)
Laminated glass about 0.8–1.0 W/(m·K)

For a pool window:

  • The room side of the window stays close to room temperature, so condensation rarely forms.
  • The pool loses less heat through the window.
  • In heated buildings, the window insulates better.

Condensation can still form where warm, humid room air meets a window surface below the dew point, for example when a cold pool borders a warm, humid room. Good ventilation or dehumidification prevents it.

Thermal Insulation and Condensation

UV Resistance

Outdoors, windows are exposed to strong ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Low-quality acrylic can turn yellow over the years. UV-stabilized cast acrylic of the kind we use does not: Hydrosight gives a 30-year warranty on the clarity and color of flat acrylic panels (see the Warranty Terms).

In laminated glass, the glass itself is not affected by UV, but the interlayers are the weak point. PVB interlayers absorb moisture and can delaminate from the edges when they stay wet permanently. Ionoplast interlayers (SGP) are much more resistant, which is why structural glass below water is laminated with them.

Hotel pool with an acrylic overflow wall in full sun in Ortisei, South Tyrol.

Hotel pool with an acrylic overflow wall in full sun in Ortisei, South Tyrol.

Scratch Resistance and Care

Glass has the harder surface. Acrylic scratches more easily and needs acrylic-safe cleaning: a soft microfiber cloth with water, mild cleaning agents for greasy dirt, never cleaners containing alcohol or solvents such as standard glass cleaner (they can cause stress cracks), and only pool robots approved for acrylic. Details are in the Operation and Maintenance Manual.

The advantage of acrylic: light scratches can be polished out with a polishing paste, even years later. A scratched glass surface cannot be repaired; the panel has to be replaced.

Test of a pool cleaning robot on an acrylic block: the robot left no scratches.

Test of a pool cleaning robot on an acrylic block: the robot left no scratches.

Which Material for Which Use?

Below the waterline – pool windows, glass pool walls and floors, public aquariums and hull windows of ships – acrylic is the better material in most cases: clearer at large thicknesses, tougher, lighter and better insulating, and available as long, bonded or curved panels.

Glass is the better choice where:

  • the surface is cleaned often or exposed to abrasion, for example windows in the superstructure or on the bridge of a ship;
  • a non-combustible material or a fire rating is required (see Fire Rating of Acrylic);
  • the panels are small and thin, as in most home aquariums, where glass is the less expensive option.

Laminated glass walls can also work in pools if the glass, the interlayer and the frame are designed for permanent contact with water.

Planning an underwater window or a glass wall? Tell us the size, shape and water depth in the configurator at the end of this page, and we will send you a quote.

Frequently Asked Questions

Your question is not answered here? Send it to us and we will be glad to answer it.

Ask Your Question
Glass or acrylic for a glass bottom pool?

Our windows in the pool floor are usually made of cast acrylic, for three reasons:

  • Condensation: The window has warm pool water above it and a cooler room below. If the panel insulates poorly, condensation forms on the underside and can drip onto furniture. Acrylic conducts heat much less than glass (0.19 W/(m·K)), so the underside stays closer to room temperature and less condensation forms.
  • Glazing overhead: The water and the panel sit above a living space. Acrylic is ductile: under heavy loads or an impact, for example a heavy object dropped into the empty pool, it deforms instead of breaking suddenly.
  • Light: Thick laminated glass can take on a green tint and lose light. Acrylic keeps its 92% light transmission, so the room below stays bright.

More in the comparison of glass and acrylic.

How thick is the acrylic of an underwater window?

There is no standard thickness. It is calculated for each window from its size and the water depth, typically between 30 and 200 mm.

How long can a glass wall be?

A single acrylic panel can be up to 11 m long. Longer walls have posts (mullions) between the panels, or two or more panels are butt-bonded into one continuous wall.

What if the acrylic gets scratched?

Light surface scratches can often be polished out with a suitable polishing paste. For deep scratches, please contact us.

How do I clean the acrylic?

Use a soft microfiber cloth moistened with water, and mild cleaning agents for greasy dirt. Never rub the acrylic dry: it becomes statically charged, attracts dust and gets scratched. Never use cleaners containing alcohol, benzene or organic solvents such as acetone, including standard glass cleaners: they attack the acrylic and can cause stress cracks (crazing). Only use pool robots that the manufacturer has approved for acrylic. Details are in the Operation and Maintenance Manual.

Can condensation form on the room side of the window?

Rarely. Acrylic insulates much better than glass (thermal conductivity 0.19 W/(m·K)), so the surface on the room side stays close to the room temperature. Condensation can still form when humid room air meets a window surface below the dew point, for example when cold pool water borders a warm, humid room. Good ventilation or dehumidification of the room prevents it.

All questions →

Pool Glass Configurator

Six short steps to your individual quote – it takes about two minutes.

Step 1 of 6

What is the window for?

This helps us choose the right material and design.

Application

Please choose an application.

Just a general question? Go to the contact form →